LAKESHORE REGIONAL NEWS: Door County, Kewaunee County, Manitowoc County, and Sheboygan County

Warren Gerds/Critic at Large: Review: ‘La La Lucille’ is merrily one for the ages in theater in Sturgeon Bay


Third Avenue Playhouse

Breaking into dance in a scene from Third Avenue Playhouse’s “La La Lucille” are the butler Alfredo (Alex M. Sabin, left) and the former vaudeville team of Lucille (Samantha Sostarich) and Thomas Tuttle (James Valcq). (Heidi Hodges)


John Smith is caught between a rock and a hard place.

“It’s your money or your wife,” the destitute dentist is told.

And so the kernel of a romp is born.

Or was born.

This romp… or musical comedy… or dance-happy farce… or merry burst of theatricality is from 1919.

How were shows done in 1919? Especially a show with music by George Gershwin in one of his first steps to lasting fame?

More than likely, they were done as presented in “La La Lucille” by the professional Third Avenue Playhouse in an astounding re-imagining by the playhouse’s co-artistic director, James Valcq.

The music – Gershwin’s music – in “La La Lucille” has a certain bounce. Perky. Syncopated. Jaunty. Stuff to be danced to.

“Stuff to be danced to” – ah, there’s the rub in this production. It is one thing to re-create the music of George Gershwin on piano. It is entirely another to set dances to that music – and another to dance in perky, syncopated and jaunty ways. Gershwin’s music has scores and recordings. The dance? What might have transpired in the original 1919 Broadway version of “La La Lucille” is re-built from the imaginations of James Valcq and co-choreographer Ryan Cappleman – and then delivered by the cast, often in whirlwind ways. The surprise of this production is not so much how it has the aura of acting and singing in a frivolous 1919 tongue-in-cheek Broadway comedy but how packed with dance action it is.

And Gershwin gets one-upped. He wrote the music, a creative task for sure. But James Valcq and Ryan Cappleman not only perform his finger-blitzes of music on piano (together and separately), but they appear on stage as a couple of goofy characters and dance the foot-blitzes of dances they have come up with. Included are flurries of tap dancing and swirling and soft shoe and grandiose flourishes and romantic gliding – for two to six dancers.

This is all very dynamic. The opening night audience Thursday latched on to the performers’ level of exhilaration and erupted in standing cheers and applause at the end. The scene was as festive as it gets in Studio Theatre.

The cast is inspired by the rare, rare opportunity to perform in a show that hasn’t been performed in 100 years (though my feeling is nobody knows for sure) with the talented James Valcq, who researched and adapted the show. Much blended expertise is called on – to sing, to dance, to act, to team – by the fired-up cast, some of whom have well-established careers and two who are being launched.

In the story, there’s a good deal of corniness. In the setup, the financially hard up John Smith and his adored wife, Lucille Tuttle Smith, can inherit $2 million ($29 million in today’s money) if they divorce. Divorce? John Smith’s rich aunt objected to Lucille – for not only did she act on the stage, she wore satin trousers! Lucille’s father’s take on the situation is “It’s foolish to be poor.” Da, da, dump. So the three and the family’s lawyer contrive to set up the appropriate inappropriateness with a co-respondent to be caught in feigned messin’ around with John Smith so Lucille can have grounds for divorce and later leap through a loophole in the will.

Along the way, the story traipses to a hotel and a honeymoon suite and honeymooners who have eloped and a house detective and a coochy-coochy dancer and a frumpy janitress and her irate knife-thrower Italian husband and the under-age honeymooning bride’s harrumphing Southern father in a fine mess.

At one point, Lucille is perplexed and says, “I don’t know what to do.” He father pauses… a light goes off. He says, “Let’s sing.” Her father happens to be portrayed by James Valcq, who concocted this situation and now breaks all sorts of “rules” by heading to the piano at the side of the stage to play and sing “Somehow It Seldom Comes True.”

James Valcq has also concocted a way to add “Swanee” to the show, even though the famous song was not part of the original “La La Lucille.” The harrumphing Southern father pours it out in saucy scene that works.

All cylinders are go with this cast.

Samantha Sostarich brims with energy and full-on expression as Lucille. She launches a HUGE note to end one number.

Adam Estes is an excellent match for her in song, dance and colorful acting as John Smith, who has been around the block in the romance area but is now devoted. He and Sostarich team in a key dance that is as light and limber as Gershwin’s music for it.

Drew Brhel, an actor of many faces, adds a few more in “La La Lucille.” Key ones are an unctuous attorney and the harrumphing father in a suiting interpretation of “Sewanee” that brings the house down.

Lydia Rose Eiche nimbly doubles in opposites, the hotsy-totsy dancer and the creaky-voiced janitress, Fanny, who in one scene manages to have four husbands.

James Valcq, as Lucille’s ex-vaudevillian hoofer father, lets out all stops in creating the show and directing and choreographing and singing, dancing and acting on stage and playing piano and, at the bows Thursday night, radiating in sheer joy of success.

Ryan Cappleman, as the honeymooning husband, has a gas chewing the scenery and creating the dances – and delivering some on stage – and playing Gershwin’s music on piano. Fantastic.

Meghan Jarecki, as the honeymooning wife, teams with Ryan Cappleman in the singing-dancing-comedy-romancing in a fully spirited performance. She is an intern in the company, and she sprints in this wonderful opportunity to be part of a remarkable production.

Alex M. Sabin sets fire to the action as the excitable husband of Fanny, always ready to flip a knife or pick a fight or let loose his over-wrought rage. He also is a part of plays on words, a key one being “Fanny.”

Side note: Much of the humor in “La La Lucille” turns on earthiness. A steady stream of mild inuendo runs through it – stuff about honeymooning and marriage and meeting in a hotel. One joke about the hotel: At the same time as John and Lucille, there are 20 Mr. and Mrs. Smiths with rooms there.

Zachary Dean, playing multiple roles, shows his versatility. Also an intern, Zachary Dean is right there delivering the goods, particularly as the house detective with an Irish brogue trying to figure out the frayed and frazzled honeymoon suite shenanigans.

James Valcq has turned back the pages to a fascinating time when George Gershwin was making big strides in his career. “La La Lucille” would kind of get lost in what was to come for George Gershwin. Hints of that come in snippets that James Valcq adds to the overture and finale – passages from “Rhapsody in Blue.” At the very end is a marvelous homage to George Gershwin when a large image of him at the piano is projected on the stage’s backdrop.

Great stuff in so many ways.


Creative: Adaptation and restoration – James Valcq of 1919 musical; music – George Gershwin; book – Fred Jackson; lyrics – Arthur Jackson, B.G. DeSylva; additional lyrics – Lou Paley, Irving Caesar, Arthur Francis; stage and musical direction – James Valcq; co-choreographers and pianists – James Valcq, Ryan Cappleman; costume design – Abby Simmons; production manager and sound design – James Balistreri; set and lighting design – James Valcq; master carpenter – Ed DiMaio; scenic artist – Isabel Kelly; managing director – Amy Frank;  co-artistic directors – James Valcq, Robert Boles


Thomas Tuttle (an ex-vaudevillian) – James Valcq

Mr. Hooper (a bill collector) – Drew Brhel

Mr. Rollins (another bill collector) – Zachary Dean

Lucille Tuttle Smith (Tuttle’s daughter) – Samantha Sostarich

Alfredo (an Italian butler) – Alex M. Sabin

John Smith (Lucille’s husband, a dentist) – Adam Estes

Reginald Grimsby (a lawyer) – Drew Brhel

Mlle. Victorine (a cabaret dancer) – Lydia Rose Eiche

Fanny (a janitress) – Lydia Rose Eiche

Mr. Miller (the room clerk) – Drew Brhel

Bellboy – Zachary Dean

Britton Hughes (a Romeo from the South) – Ryan Cappleman

Peggy Hughes (his Juliet) – Meghan Jarecki

Waiter – Drew Brhel

Duffy (house detective) – Zachary Dean

Colonel Marion (Peggy’s father) – Drew Brhel

Running time: 2½ hours

Remaining performances: To Sept. 1: 7:30 p.m. Wednesdays-Saturdays, 2 p.m. Sundays



Musical selections

Act I

Overture – Ryan Cappleman and James Valcq at piano

“Kindly Pay Us” – Tuttle, Hooper, Rollins

“When You Live in a Furnished Flat” – Alfredo, Tuttle, Lucille

“The Best of Everything” – John, Hooper, Rollins

“Tra-La-La” – Lucille, John

“It’s Hard to Tell” – Tuttle, John, Lucille

“From Now On” – John, Lucille

“Tee-Oodle Um-Bum-Bo” – Lucille, Tuttle

“Scandal Walk” – Mlle. Victorine

“Finale Act One” – Lucille, Fanny, John, Tuttle

Act II

“Honeymoon Suite” – Mr. Miller, Bellboy, Britton, Peggy

“Nobody But You” – Peggy, Britton

“I Won’t Say I Will” – Fanny

“There’s More to the Kiss” – Peggy, John

“Finale Act Two” – Duffy, Peggy, Britton, Alfredo, John, Fanny


“Opening Act Three” – Duffy, Peggy, Britton, Alfredo, John, Fanny

“I’ll Build a Stairway to Paradise” – Lucille

“Somehow It Seldom Comes True” – Tuttle

“Swanee” – Colonel Marion

“Do It Again” – John, Lucille

“Finale: The Love of a Wife” – The Husbands

   “Ten Commandments of Love” – The Wives

   “Nobody But You” (Reprise) – Company


Added notes

+ George Gershwin in 1919 was age 21 when he wrote the music for “La La Lucille.”

+ Also in 1919, “Swanee” became George Gershwin’s first national hit. Written with lyricist Irving Caesar, the song became the calling card of famed showman Al Jolson.

+ At the Gershwin Enterprises website under “Happening Now” is a notice for this production under an image of the original program cover, noting, “George Gershwin’s first musical receives a once-in-a-generation (or more) production at Door County’s Third Avenue Playhouse!”

NEXT: “Boomerang” by Will Durst, Sept. 4-7.

THE VENUE: The 84-seat Studio Theatre is located in Third Avenue Playhouse, 239 N. Third Ave., in downtown Sturgeon Bay. The space is tucked into the corner off the main theater of the playhouse. Entry is along a long hallway off the playhouse’s lobby. To the left on the hallway wall is a growing display of photos of past productions. Studio Theatre is a black-box theater; the walls, sloped floor and support beams are black. The permanent fold-down theater seats are of red fabric seats on red metal, wooden arms and curved wood backs with metal edging. The focus is the stage, which is rectangular and has no curtain. With the closeness of the audience to the stage, the aura is the audience is part of what is transpiring in the play. Co-artistic directors James Valcq and Robert Boles have operated the playhouse since 2011. The origins of Third Avenue Playhouse date to 1999. The playhouse previously was a movie theater, the Donna.

Copyright 2020 Nexstar Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Don't Miss

More Don't Miss

Coronavirus News

More Coronavirus

Trending Stories

Your Local Election HQ

More Election

Local Sports

High School Sports Xtra: Boys basketball primer

High School Sports Xtra: Valley stars reach 1,000 career points, Bay Area teams start strong

Green Bay women open with 69-61 win over Drake

Hallum's hat trick leads Gamblers past Chicago

Conference contenders dominate in girls basketball openers

Phoenix set to begin Will Ryan Era against Minnesota